Blog Categories

What happened to my sheets?

One luxury I enjoy is really soft sheets. They’re not always the most expensive, in fact the highest thread count is not always the softest sheet. I used to get Wamsutta Elite Sateen but they don’t make them any more. These were like sleeping on a cloud of fluffy whipped cream. Luckily, I had bought three sets before they stopped making them and figured they would  last for years. Imagine my horror when a few weeks ago, we discovered a tear in the bottom sheet.  This was not a tiny tear – it was two feet long!  This can’t be – it’s my Elite Sateen! But the sheets were old so I accepted that it was wear & tear and sewed it back together. The next time, the same sheet came up ripped again, this time in shreds. I decided that you can’t sew a sheet back together and threw it away. (actually, I cut it up into cleaning rags).

So, on to the next set of Wamsutta’s.  After two nights on the bed, this bottom sheet was torn too – multiple times. Two sheets in shreds?!  An investigation was in order. First of all, both the tears happened on HIS side of the bed so without placing blame, I asked Denis how he thinks this could have happened.  He reminded me the sheets were old and his skin is rougher and these things happen. Then I slowly glanced down at his bare feet. The nail on his big toe was so long, if he sat on the roof and stuck out his foot, that toe could shade the entire patio on a sunny day!

“You could slice a ham with that toe nail,” I said. “That’s what happened to the sheets!”  He refused to believe his toe nail was responsible, but I know different. If the last Wamsutta Elite gets destroyed, I’m buying him an industrial nail file, or maybe an electric sander.

40 Responses

  1. Judy says:

    I’m on the hunt for another set of the Wamsutta elite sateen sheets but lo and behold everything I read says that the company no longer makes them. In the time of COVID this is hardly a disaster BUT I want what I want!!!!!! Any ideas for another brand. My last set of Wamsutta sheets are fine but heavy and stiff, although they didn’t feel that way in the store. They are okay, maybe a B, but not the A+ of the elite sateen sheets. Good-bye Wamsutta.

    • Nancy Kaye says:

      Surprised to find others searching for Wamsutta Elite Sateen sheets. The one set I have is near its end of life, so I save them to use when I want a special nighttime treat. I have spent a fortune trying to find replacement sheets that feel the same as Wamsutta Elite Sateen, but I’ve not had any luck. Has anyone else found a replacement sheet?

      • Sharla says:

        My last Wamsutta Elite Sateen fitted sheet has just gone to shreds… did anyone find a satisfactory replacement? I’m so sad!! I don’t want to spend hundreds of dollars only to be dissatisfied. damn Wamsutta for discontinuing a fabulous model!

  2. Holly says:

    How funny that all these years later I came upon your posts about…Wamsutta Elite Sateen sheets. I’m considering sewing a fitted queen sheet out of an old king — that’s how desperate I am to keep sleeping on these great sheets.

    I did find some Jonathan Adler percale sheets that come pretty close to the softness of our favorite old Wamsuttas. I got mine at Nordstrom Rack and liked them so much that I looked for another set online. These are the sheets: https://www.amazon.com/Jonathan-Adler-Scale-Sheet-Chocolate/dp/B00AG4GTN2 . Be aware – I notice that some of his other sheets are cotton/poly blends 🙁 but the ones I love are 400 t.c. cotton. Lovely.

    Anyway, I had a blast looking through your website! Thanks for the good memories.

    • Susie says:

      I read this blog because I, too, have had problems with my last 2 sets of Wamsutta sheets … different thread counts (from 650 and higher). I can confirm that the bottom sheets DEFINITELY rip, and not just on hubby’s side! I regularly get a pedicure (my one vice) and the ONLY sheets I’ve owned that ripped are the Wamsutta (which were purchased from Bed Bath and Beyond!) I have called them about this and they agreed to “work with us”….. We shall see.

      BTW, I’ve been purchasing our sheets for more than 25 years; the last two sets both ripped (Wamsutta brand). I would really like any feedback on this please!?

      • Guilty Sheet Shredder says:

        Too Funny. Came upon this while searching for these specific sheets. It’s Dec 21st and I am going to start Christmas shopping a little early this year. My wife loves these sheets, so I thought they would make a great gift.

        We have gone through several set of these sheets over the years as these Use To wear thin / out around my feet. In my case, the sheets stopped wearing thin / out around my feet once I found out / started taking medication for Restless legs syndrome (RLS). Bottom line: My RLS really accelerated the wear around my feet — the sheets should receive some kind of high withstands “RSL Sheet Shredding” husbands award. Maybe include something about their nasty toes nails…

  3. Weston says:

    My toe nails are not the problem. But 6 fitted sheets I’ve ran my dreams through.

  4. Christie says:

    I too am looking for the wamsutta elite sateens!!!! Maybe they discontinued because they are a little then but SO SOFT! Unfortunately I only have 2 pillow cases that I don’t let anyone use. Please respond if anyone has found something comparable.

    • Marie says:

      Hi ~ did you ever find any wamsutta elite sateens? MY pillowcases have about had it but I can’t find any of this specific Wamsutta anywhere.
      If not, did you find a similar replacement?

      Thanks!

  5. Sue says:

    Did you ever find a solution for the torn bottom sheet. I have exactly the same problem. And in hubby’s side. Long 2 foot) tear in bottom of the sheet at foot level. This is the second sheet ruined in this way. He is a restless sleeper.We have recently addressed toenails but the second sheet came up torn anyway. The sheet fits well, that isn’t the problem. Any enlightenment?

    • Jenny says:

      Yes. The serenity prayer comes to mind. God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can, and wisdom to know the difference. Love him unconditionally! ?

  6. Marion says:

    I too have been searching for the warmsutta elite sheets…. love them and the ones I have had for years are wearing out. Please post if you find a replacement

  7. Michelle says:

    I just discovered a third fitted sheet torn to shreds in exact place where HIS feet hit it. First two were thin-ish but flannel and third was high thread count. Unbelievable. Didn’t think it was possible his fossilized lizard feet could really do this but not finding any other plausible answer.

  8. Sandy says:

    If anyone can replace the wamsutta elite sateen sheets please let me know I have tried so many that are “SATEEN” isheets but no comparisson to WAMSUTTA ELITE SAATEEN

  9. Jenny says:

    I have not been able to find a comparable set of sheets to my old Wamsutta Elite Sateen’s. I bought some Hudson Park at Bloomingdale’s and they were better than most but not soft enough. I did learn something, though. I was told that cotton has tiny little (practically invisible) fibers that stand up and if you iron the sheets, you will flatten those fibers and the sheets will be softer. I tried it and it does make a difference. So now I’m using ironed Hudson Park, but without ironing, I can’t sleep on them.

    • Danielle says:

      Hi Jenny: I just ran across your post about sateen sheets, so I thought I’d respond. At the risk of being sales pitchy (I work for Cuddledown), we offer what I think anyway, are the softest sateen sheets anywhere! They’re 400 thread count, made with fine, long-staple cotton and I’ve never slept on anything smoother. They are pricey compared to some, but well worth it in comfort. I’m told they last well too – not sure about snaggly hubby toenails though?! I’ve only had mine for 2 years, so don’t know yet how they’ll wear long-term. Family and friends I’ve gifted with them, love them, and our customers totally love them too.

    • Stacey Saladyga says:

      So, it’s not just me! I bought my first and only Elite Sateen sheets way back in 2001 as a birthday gift to myself. I was turning mid-thirtysomething and felt I deserved a thread count over 200 at that point in my life, so I found a set on sale for $60.00, which was a huge splurge for a working single mom in the D.C. area. I was now Queen of my sleeping universe and I made a solemn oath to never go back to anything below 500.
      Now, 13 years later I still cannot relinquish the bits that are left of that set, such as the lone pillowcase that is coming apart at the seams and the flat sheet that is actually used as a playing surface for my sons Legoes. Is that a sacrilege?
      That set was a queen size and I now own a king bed, so of course I struck out to find a replacement set for the bigger bed and to my great dismay I cannot find anything that comes close. Thanks a lot, Wamsutta, for creating the addiction only to withdraw my one and only fix. If you find a worthy substitute, please share with the world. The only story that is worse than mine is, indeed, the toenail one.

  10. Tish says:

    Jenny,
    Did you ever find a replacement? I’m in this situation now. I love my Wamsutta Elite Sateen Sheets and I want to get another one.

    Thanks,
    Tish

  11. Jeremy says:

    Did you ever have any luck finding a decent replacement? My last set of elites finally died this weekend after 15 years or blissfull sleep. Argh.

    • Jenny says:

      I wish… But I did not find a comparable replacement. I think Sfrerra Brothers would work but they cost as much as a used car!

  12. sue says:

    Go Steelers!!!!!!!! They won! yes. We had a couple of friends up tonite and thought they might lose, but never lost faith!! Yes they won!!! Go big Ben! Heinz Ward, and the whole Steelers team! Thank God Pennsylvania has one awesome team! The other PA TEAM WOULD BE THE EAGLES, Michael Vick is an asshole who does not deserve any forgiveness! Who drowns dogs, electricutes them, hangs them and beats them and serves 18 months in prison and all of a sudden he has served his time???? When a criminal in this world commits a crime so hanous and commits murder, it’s ok to let him or her go after 18 months? Why is it ok to let some dog murderer go after 18 months when he has commited murder over 100 times to innocent dogs? Dogs are so precious, they can’t wait for you to come home, the tails are wagging, the love is over pooring! To kill something this beautiful, because they don’t meet up to your anger, your rage and your thrill to see dogs rip eachother apart??? You are a dispicible human being! I can’t help but think about those dogs that were tortured, electricuted!, and drowned! Screw you Michael Vick. Spell Dog backwards!!! GOD! Mans best friend!! Find God yourself Vick and I also would never let you have the privilige of sharing your life with a beautiful DOG. Sue, Mike, Teka and Kya our very loved and spoiled dogs. God Bless all animals!!

    • Rhonda says:

      Very nicely put into words about Vick, Sue. I’m glad Alanta got rid of him 🙂
      I do not like him for the same reason you just stated. Really cruel what he did. Those dogs didn’t deserve the torture Vick committed. Horrible!!!…
      We went out for dinner tonight, “Sports Bar”. They had the Falcons game on and it sucked. We didn’t even stay for the 4th quarter because the score in the 3rd
      quarter was 42 to 21…Green Bay 🙁
      Don’t know what the score ended up being. I was a bit frustrated at the time and still am a little but I’m sure Atlanta lost. Green Bay is a tough team…

      • sue says:

        thanks Rhonda!
        Sue

      • sue says:

        Rhonda,
        I’m sorry that your team lost. But you would have been proud of Green Bay last weekend when they beat the Philadelphia Eagles!! Michael Vick shot his mouth off about the first time that Green Bay beat them, he said, “We would have won the game if I were playing the whole game.” Well look who played the whole game last weekend and look who lost!!!! Me and Mike were laughing so hard and so happy to say goodbye to the Eagles!! I really respect the Atlanta Falcons for getting rid of Vick for what he did and made him pay back the 40 million dollars to the team. They wanted nothing to do with him and said they would never take him back. So I’m sorry that the Falcons lost. Take care and I’m glad that you share the same opinion of the dog killer that we do and so many others!!!
        Have a great day sista!!

        Sue

        • Rhonda says:

          It’s okay, Sue. I’m over it 🙂
          Falcons played really well this year, but now they are playing tougher teams here at the end of the season. I’ve been watching football since I was a teen with my dad and I still enjoy it. I watch baseball too, but football is my favorite sport to watch…
          Hope Vick felt like an idiot by saying what he said. Played the whole game and lost…lol…funny! After Vick left Atlanta. I was hoping nobody in the NFL would want him but you see someboby wanted him. In my opinion, he’s no good for anybody. He will never be the star he set himself out to being when he first started playing football. My opinion of course 🙂

          Take care,
          Rhonda

  13. sister dearest says:

    They should his and hers sides, yours soft, thin and comfy, and his out of chain-mail.

  14. sue says:

    How about some thick socks guys? Cover those badboys up! For the love of God, save our sheets!!!

    sue

  15. Anna Cherry says:

    Not too long ago my guy was walking fast across the room with a coffee mug. He spilled some on my bare foot, the floor and the cat. I brought it to his attention. He denied it and went on his merry way.

    It’s just like a man to deny his toe nail ripped the sheets. Steve and Denis would get along great.

  16. Will says:

    OMG! I did this to some sheets recently too. Except that it was my rough, dry heels that caused the tear and it was over a longer period of time. I kept looking at the sheets wondering why they get so worn out in that area.
    Why are we men so neglectful of our feet? I’ve started the scraping process every couple of days after my shower.
    Maybe it’s time for couples pedicures, that way you always know he is keeping them up.

  17. MrsNews says:

    I am with Becky on this one!! Ewwwwwwwwwwwww!

  18. Joe M says:

    Hey Jenny I had to write and just suggest something. You said you were no longer able to find the Elite Sateen I just wanted to make a great suggestion. I used to work for TJ Maxx and we carried that all the time, even after its not available in regular stores (sometimes it takes a while to reach our stores). Just a thought to check out. You don’t have to even run all over just give the store a call.

  19. Rhonda says:

    Jenny, I would have Denis get a trim if I were you or the 3rd set of sheets are gonna be gonners…
    Fingernails and toe nails can be sharp as razors if not trimmed up. Glad you figured out what was tearing your sheets…
    Come on Denis don’t ruin Jenny’s favorite sheets with razor sharp toe nails 🙂

    Take care,
    Rhonda

  20. Becky says:

    Ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww!!! LOL!

Leave a Comment

Looking for a lost episode of my show? Sorry, I have no access to old shows.